From Samurai to Fantasy: Total War Games Ranked by Fans and Critics
Introduction
The Total War series has stood the test of time, evolving from a modest real-time strategy concept to a global franchise adored by millions. Combining real-time battles with turn-based empire management, the series allows players to command vast armies and lead civilizations through history—or, in some cases, fantasy. Over the past 20+ years, Creative Assembly has released numerous entries, each pushing the boundaries of strategy gaming in its own way. But how do these games stack up against one another?
This blog takes you through a curated list of all the total war games ranked , judged by gameplay mechanics, innovation, and community impact. Whether you’re a newcomer or a seasoned general, this breakdown will help you decide which title to pick up next.
1. Shogun 2 – The Gold Standard
A fan-favorite and often considered the most polished entry, Shogun 2 stands out for its intimate setting and precise game design. Focused on Japan’s Sengoku period, it strikes a perfect balance between accessibility and depth. The visuals, atmospheric combat, and polished mechanics make this the pinnacle of the series for many.
2. Three Kingdoms – Diplomacy Reimagined
This game redefined diplomacy in Total War. With its strong narrative and dynamic relationship system, Three Kingdoms offers one of the most sophisticated political mechanics in the franchise. Its art style, based on Chinese historical literature, also adds a refreshing cultural richness.
3. Warhammer 2 – Fantasy Unleashed
When Creative Assembly partnered with Games Workshop, expectations were high—and Warhammer 2 delivered. This title introduced powerful factions, magic-based warfare, and an enormous campaign map, making it a dream for fantasy lovers. Despite early skepticism, it became a monumental success.
4. Empire – A New Age Begins
Empire introduced 3D naval battles and a global campaign map, marking a bold leap forward. Though buggy at launch, its ambition and scale were undeniable. Its blend of gunpowder warfare and colonial politics made it a standout entry, especially after patches and mods refined its experience.
5. Medieval 2 – Timeless Warfare
Though it’s an older title, Medieval 2 holds a special place in fans’ hearts. The game features large-scale melee combat and is highly moddable, with custom campaigns like Lord of the Rings Total War still popular today. Its legacy in modding culture is unmatched.
6. Rome – A Classic Reborn
Rome: Total War set the standard for what a historical strategy game could achieve. With its distinct factions, clean UI, and unforgettable campaign in ancient Italy, it remains a nostalgic favorite. It perfectly captures the essence of conquest and expansion.
7. Warhammer – The Beginning of Fantasy
The original Warhammer entry was a gamble that paid off. It reshaped the franchise by introducing mythical creatures and aggressive combat mechanics. Though its sequel improved on nearly every aspect, the original deserves credit for redefining the Total War formula.
8. Attila – Dark Horse of the Series
Often overlooked, Attila delivers intense mechanics and dynamic events. It excels at portraying a world on the brink of collapse and adds grim realism with its campaign devastation mechanics. While not as accessible as others, it’s a rewarding experience for veterans.
9. Total War Saga: Troy – Myth and History
Troy blends mythological elements with grounded warfare. It’s far superior to its Saga predecessor, Thrones of Britannia, thanks to its engaging campaign mechanics and distinct art style. Though not a mainline title, it punches above its weight.
10. Rome 2 – A Mixed Legacy
Rome 2 had a rough launch but has since improved through updates and expansions. While its campaign map and politics system are impressive, it lacks the tightness and clarity of its predecessor, placing it lower on this list.
11. Napoleon – Strategic Excellence
Though often seen as an extension of Empire, Napoleon deserves recognition for its detailed campaign, improved AI, and historical accuracy. It’s a more refined version of Empire, albeit on a smaller scale.
12. Medieval – A Glimpse into the Past
The original Medieval might be hard to revisit today due to dated graphics and mechanics, but it paved the way for one of the franchise’s best sequels. It holds a special place for veteran players who value deep strategic gameplay.
13. Thrones of Britannia – Missed Opportunities
Despite its modern visuals, Thrones of Britannia suffers from slow pacing, limited unit variety, and a dull map. It attempted to focus on post-Roman Britain but failed to deliver a memorable or dynamic campaign.
The Total War franchise is a celebration of strategy, history, and innovation. Each title has brought something new to the table, and while some entries have aged better than others, there’s no denying the series’ overall impact. From the intimate duels of Shogun 2 to the magical chaos of Warhammer 2, there’s a Total War game for every kind of strategist. This comprehensive list highlights the evolution of a beloved series and gives both newcomers and veterans a clear idea of where to start—or where to return. Among these, one thing remains clear: there’s no wrong place to jump in when it comes to the total war games ranked by fans and critics alike.