Nana Ji Hair Oil vs Nidhi’s Grandmaa Secret Hair Oil – Which Is Better for You?
I have seen so many ads for herbal hair oils, in which 2 brands stood out at the top – Nidhi’s Grandmaa Secret and Avimee Herbal, also known as Nanaji hair oil!
And I started on a journey to find which hair oil is better. As I was looking for a solution to my hair fall, I delved into researching, reading, and understanding both products.
I ended up doing my own experiments, and what I found will shock you! Yes, the results are totally unexpected, and I would recommend you read till the end to make the best decision for your hair health.
Nana Ji Hair Oil vs NIdhi’s Grandmaa Secret Hair Oil
| Feature | Nanaji Hair Oil | Grandmaa Secret Hair Oil |
| Brand Origin | Founded by 85-year-old Nanaji (viral brand on social media) | Handcrafted Ayurvedic hair care rooted in grandmother’s nuskhas |
| Product Type | Herbal hair oil | Ayurvedic therapeutic hair oil |
| Best For | Daily hair nourishment | Hair fall, dandruff, growth, and premature greying |
Ingredients Comparison
Nanaji Oil:
- Nanaji oil is a herbal blend created with a mix of sesame, coconut, castor, almond, neem, and argan oils.
- It’s enriched with popular Ayurvedic herbs like bhringraj, amla, jatamansi, fenugreek, and mulethi
- These ingredients are known to support overall hair strength and growth.
- The oil also includes essential oils like rosemary, tea tree, and lavender, which give it a strong herbal aroma and a tingling sensation on the scalp.
- While it’s preservative-free and well-formulated, the presence of essential oils may not suit those with sensitive scalps or individuals seeking a gentler, more traditional oiling experience.
Nidhi’s Grandmaa Secret Hair Oil:
- Grandmaa Secret takes a more rooted, slow-care approach with a base of virgin coconut, sesame, and castor oils.
- Oils are slow-infused with Ayurvedic herbs for deeper penetration and nourishment.
- It features a powerful blend of bhringraj, hibiscus, curry leaves, brahmi, tulsi, and methi, making it particularly effective for tackling hair fall, dandruff, and premature greying.
- What truly sets it apart is its simplicity – no strong essential oils, no synthetic fragrance, and absolutely no irritants.
- It’s a scalp-soothing, grandma-style hair oil that feels like a homemade remedy.
Performance & Results
| Concern | Nana Ji Hair Oil | Grandmaa Secret Hair Oil |
| Hair Fall | Reduces hair fall with consistent use | Noticeable reduction in 6-8 weeks (clinically proven) |
| Dandruff | Mild relief | Antifungal herbs like neem and tulsi show better results |
| Greying | No significant claims | Prevents premature greying with regular use |
| Scalp Health | It can be drying for some due to the stronger ingredients | Moisturises, soothes and nourishes the scalp deeply |
Final Verdict?
While Nana Ji Hair Oil is a decent option for basic nourishment, Grandmaa Secret Hair Oil stands out, especially for women experiencing post-partum hairfall, hormonal hairfall, or premature greying.
As a mom, Grandmaa secret worked really well on my specific issues, while Nana Ji’s hair oil just didn’t target those issues.
Who should pick which?
- For daily nourishment, you can go for Nana Ji Hair oil. It is good for people with dry scalp.
- For more advanced and targeted treatment, go for Nidhi’s Grandmaa Secret hair oil. It is best for people with sensitive skin, premature greying, dandruff, rosacea, and post-partum hair fall.
Why Nidhi’s Grandmaa Secret Wins:
It gave more consistent, deeper scalp healing. The absence of strong essential oils makes it better for sensitive scalps and postpartum hair care.
While both oils are preservative-free, Avimee still uses essential oils for scent and added benefits, which can sometimes irritate sensitive skin. Grandmaa Secret is 100% natural, with no synthetic fragrance or irritants, offering a more authentic, homemade hair oil experience.